Jokowi needs to learn the difference between popular and populist

On Wednesday, Joko Widodo will serve his 100th day as president of Indonesia. Though he has achieved some important victories, things are not going well for him right now, and some of the decisions he is making are likely to make things worse in the future. I’ve described why in the Nikkei Asian Review:

Elizabeth Pisani reviews Joko Widodo's first 100 days as Indonesian president in the Nikkei Asian Review

(Read the rest of the Nikkei piece here. I conclude that Jokowi’s need to appear decisive in the wake of a handful of grave political blunders has led to some very poor policy-making.)

The appointment of Budi Gunawan as police chief has turned up the volume on a chorus that sings doubts about the president’s political independence. As I said in the essay, that there are only two likely explanations for his attempt to appoint a man widely suspected of corruption to head the national police: either Jokowi is bowing to the demands of the political Old Guard, or he is grossly incompetent. On the evidence of this interview given on his 98th day at the helm (which I had not seen when I wrote the Nikkei essay) I would have to agree with Daniel Ziv that the Indonesian president is not currently in charge of his own faculties, let alone the country.

It’s almost painful to watch Jokowi’s performance during that interview, the more so because it seems so tragically reminiscent of the once grandiose Sukarno’s speech when he formally handed over power to his successor Suharto, who had essentially kept the father of the nation under house arrest for over a year. Interestingly, while footage of Sukarno’s inauguration is all over Youtube, it is very difficult to track down the film of the broken president’s handover to his very decisive successor. (I think I saw the heart-breaking archival footage of that scene in Curtis Levy’s documentary about Indonesia, Riding the Tiger.)

I hope Indonesians will be able to temper their inevitable impatience with the weakness Jokowi is now showing. Let’s not forget that while his opponent Prabowo Subianto would certainly be more decisive and forceful, he would very probably force through things that are a lot worse than the we’ve seen from Jokowi so far, despite his alarming missteps. It’s worth noting, too, the total absence of Vice President Jusuf Kalla from the current scene. Anyone might think that he was trying to distance himself from the president while biding his time for the inevitable takeover…

1 Comment on "Jokowi needs to learn the difference between popular and populist"

  1. Hi Elizabeth, I’m reading “Indonesia, Etc” right now and enjoying it immensely. The Jokowi interview you embedded here really is painful to watch. Initially I thought that he was on something. But from the way he very carefully hewed to the select words/phrases, I think he was just very uncomfortable in this limitation (or had to take something to get through it…).

    I admit to having been caught in Jokowimania before the election (from the safe distance of the US), and very much relishing the Prabowo vs Jokowi spats on my friends’ Facebook pages. And then, I happened to be in Jakarta during the Gunawan debacle, and was quite disillusioned by it. I think your former explanation makes the most sense, that Jokowi must keep the Old Guard happy to preserve his fragile hold on power.

    I suppose I can understand people’s preference for decisiveness and forcefulness, but those traits are usually coupled with an unshakeable sense of never being wrong (see: Bush, George W.). So my rule of thumb is that candidates who delight in showing their decisiveness and forcefulness make bad statespersons.

    Anyway, I look forward to reading more of your posts and books!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*